Monday, July 20, 2015

Saying goodbye to Community Inclusion



Today was the 15-year anniversary of my being hired for my first job in my chosen field. 

I spent it packing up my office. 

I haven’t lost my job. But I’ve lost the part of my job that I loved most.

For those who aren’t familiar with my job and my field – I’m a Behavior Specialist, working with people who have developmental disabilities. My role is to figure out what need a person’s behavior meets – attention, control, stimulation, escape from physical or emotional pain, etc. – and make a plan to help them meet it without doing dangerous or inappropriate things. It’s a wonderful, interesting, fun job, and despite its challenges and the modest size of the paycheck I can’t imagine doing anything else.

Before I was a Behavior Specialist, I worked in a Community Inclusion program. It was for adults with severe cognitive and physical disabilities, and the emphasis was on helping them to achieve their own goals. If they wanted a job, we’d help them find one. If there wasn’t one, we’d create one. If they didn’t have the ability and desire to do any kind of job, we’d find out what they COULD do and what they DID want, and go out and do the hell out of that. We had people learning to read, learning to communicate more effectively, learning to order their own food, learning to make paper, learning to paint and draw, learning to play music, learning to hold and count their own money, learning to feed themselves, learning to take care of plants, learning to talk to people they met in the community, learning to cook… going to parks and zoos and fairs and stores and bowling alleys and swimming pools and restaurants and concerts and bars… and just trying all kinds of new things to find out what they could do and what they liked doing. 

And it was GOOD. It had joy. It had fun. It had a sense of hope that people could be doing better a year from now than they are today. It met people where they were at and helped them get closer to where they wanted to go. It had people smiling and laughing and socializing and learning, who used to do nothing but scream and hit. It had people who were not able to work, still able to do SOMETHING worthwhile. It was a beautiful thing in the lives of the people we served there, and in my life. 
 
And when I got promoted to Behavior Specialist, I stayed involved in that program to the extent that I could. Eventually my office was there, and that worked great because it meant I’d see most of the people on my caseload every day, and I still got to help them participate in the part of their day they loved most.

And I poured the best of myself, my best work, all the creativity and effort and passion and humor and love I have, into that program.


That program has been shut down.


It closed not because it was failing to accomplish what it was made to accomplish, but because political and legal decisions are made by politicians and judges – by people who have no actual experience with the things they’re making decisions about.

There was a series of funding changes over several years that gradually made it impossible to do the job with the amount of money the state would pay for the work. Each change, to an outsider, would make logical sense; but to someone actually doing the job, it was an obvious mistake. And each time the government cut the funding, they never considered that the needs of the people we serve hadn’t decreased just because the funding had. They still needed physical assistance to eat and drink, use the bathroom, get in and out of chairs, and communicate… let alone the help they needed in order to learn new physical skills, experience new places and activities, learn and practice the rudiments of social interaction that would help them be more safe and appropriate in community settings, follow the routines that they depended upon in order to feel happy and safe and in control of their lives. All the things that Community Inclusion programs were created for. Apparently, the government thought these things aren’t important for people with disabilities. 

What’s important to the government is that we pour the majority of the (limited) resources into getting people jobs. And that’s a worthwhile goal, it really is. Having a job gives people money, which gives people control, and that’s something people with disabilities often lack. In fact, most of the challenging behavior I see comes from people who have a lack of control, and I am all for helping them get control in safe ways. By all means, if someone can get a job, we should support them in doing so.

But: it feels like we sacrificed the quality of life of the people with the most profound disabilities, the ones who won't benefit from the employment programs because they lack the physical or cognitive ability to do the kind of work that employers are willing to pay for. 

I understand why legislators and lawyers made the decisions they did, I really do… and maybe they meant well. But the end result is that people’s lives suffered. This beautiful and worthwhile endeavor;
this place that ensured the most easily overlooked people would have a time and place each day to get someone’s full attention; this place that brought joy into lives that had been joyless; this place that gave a predictable routine and rhythm to lives that used to be in chaos; this place that helped the world's most lonely people to build this wonderful, quirky little community where they were happy, safe, and comfortable... all this was disbanded because it was no longer considered worthwhile by people who had never even seen it in action.

All through the past month, I’ve had a line from the Kipling poem “If” running through my head:

“If you can bear to see ... the things you gave your life to, broken,
And stoop and build ‘em up with worn-out tools…”

I hope we can rebuild, in some way, what that program had achieved. I sure as hell am gonna try.

But for now, I grieve for what’s been broken.

Friday, December 5, 2014

The real enemy


Is not black 
Is not white 
Is not the poor 
Is not the rich
Is not the police 
Is not the civilian 
Is not the liberal 
Is not the conservative 
Is not the powerful 
Is not the powerless. 
The real enemy 
Is that within each human being 
Which sees other human beings as things. 
Whether things to use 
Or things to abuse 
Or things to destroy 
Or things to ignore 
Doesn’t matter in the end. 
Whenever we treat people as things, 
The enemy is us. 
Let us never forget who the real enemy is. 
Let us join together, 
For only in joining together do we fight 
The real enemy.

© John M. Munzer

Wednesday, August 6, 2014

My bad habit


I’ve always processed my thoughts and feelings by writing them, particularly when I’m upset. As a kid I did that on paper; now that I can type faster than I can write, I do it on the computer. That’s not a bad habit in itself.

BUT:



I’ve gotten into the habit of doing it, not in a journal or a Word document or even in this blog, but in e-mails and on Facebook posts. Frequently, I start to write them out, look at what I’ve written and realize “That’s something that’s okay for me to feel, but not something that’s kind/ helpful/ wise/ true/ logical/ necessary to say to this person/ an appropriate response to what this person said/ a complete or articulate thought”, and then I hit “Delete” rather than “Send” or “Post”.



But sometimes, the internal editor doesn’t intervene, and I go ahead and send or post something that would have been better written in a journal and then let go. It’s like instead of writing it in a journal, I wrote it on someone ELSE’S journal. Which is being published world-wide.



And that’s when I get myself in trouble. Because I’m more likely to make this mistake when I’m writing about something that upsets me, these things tend to be dripping with sarcasm and invective rather than clearly thought-out, logical points that can easily be followed by people who aren't me. And they also tend to be loaded with anger that isn’t directed at the particular person, or even solely that particular issue, but ALL the anger I have about ALL of the things that are wrong with the world. So I’m not only venting anger inappropriately at the wrong person, I’m not even really explaining what I’m angry about, or that it’s not about the person to whom I’m writing. 

AND I'm doing it in writing, so neither of us are seeing each other's faces, hearing tone of voice, seeing body language. So other people aren't getting the cues that would have told them this isn't about them. And I'm not getting the initial cues that would have told me I was out of line and need to stop and apologize, rather than continue the inappropriate rage-splosion.

Again, all this in someone else's journal. Which is being published world-wide. Where, literally, everyone and their grandmother can read it.


So if I do that to someone who is a LOT more reasonable than I am (which, thankfully, happened last time I did this), the response is simply a baffled “What was that about?” And here, I should offer my deep thanks to the people who are a lot more reasonable than I am, as well as my deep apologies to anyone who's been at the receiving end of one of my misplaced rants.


If I do it to someone who, like me, tends to get defensive if they feel attacked (especially in a public setting) … well, really, when that blows up in my face I’m dealing with the natural consequences of my mistakes there. But it was unfair for me to do this to the person in the first place.



So, I’m going to try and get into the habit of using a Word document that I can save or delete when I’m done venting, rather than venting at the universe in general in a format with a "Send" button.

At the very least, if I'm gonna share a rant with everyone and their grandmother, I'll make sure to edit it so it's at least sorta coherent, and put it in my own blog where it belongs.




In that spirit, I waited a few days after writing this before posting it. I felt that my internal editor needed the practice.

Thursday, March 20, 2014

The Throne of Judgement



Four people died, and found themselves standing together before the Throne of Judgment. The Throne was a mile high, made of gold, and mounted atop a great golden gate wide enough for armies to march through. And the figure upon the throne appeared like a thunderstorm with a golden crown. From the Throne boomed a deep voice commanding “Stand before me and tell me why you belong in my kingdom”.

The first person to stand before the throne said, “I’m gay. I’ve heard different opinions about what you think of that, but I know I’m just how you made me. And you talked a lot about love, so I figured that was more important to you than my orientation and …”

The voice from the throne interrupted, “You are not the kind of person
who belongs in my kingdom. Go to the next door.”

The second person to stand before the throne said “I was a straight ally. I knew that the Bible said some things that seemed to be anti-gay, but I looked at the behavior of Jesus Christ – the things He said and did, the people he hung out with – and I figured that if I was going to err one way or the other, I should err on the side of loving sinners rather than hating sin. I felt that the verses condemning homosexuals must have been misinterpreted, or based on a specific cultural context that wasn’t intended to apply for the time and place I lived in. And I looked at how the Bible described Jesus and thought that, in any debate, you would be on the side of the underdog.”

The voice from the throne intoned in deep disapproval, “You were wrong. I expect to be obeyed, and I expected you to tell others to obey me. You are not the kind of person who belongs in my kingdom. Go to the next door.”

The third to stand before the throne said “I tried my best to follow what the Bible said. It was hard, because I knew that you don’t approve of homosexuality, but I also knew you wanted me to treat gay people with respect. So I voted against gay marriage, and I taught my own children that gays were sinners like any of us, and needed to repent of their sin, but I didn’t preach against homosexuality or try to make the gays stop being gay or anything like that.” 

The voice from the throne thundered “You didn’t go far enough. You should have told everyone that they should fear my wrath. You are not the kind of person who belongs in my kingdom. Go to the next door.”

The fourth person to stand before the throne said “I told everyone who’d listen, and lots of people who wouldn’t, that the gays were going to hell for their sinful, unnatural acts unless they repented. I feared for their souls and I told them so. I refused to allow them to take communion in my church unless they were willing to repent – and you’d be amazed, NONE of them did. But I know I obeyed, and I tried to get them to obey, because I knew this moment would come for all of us and we should be afraid.”

The voice said “You sound like the kind of person who might belong in my kingdom. Tell me, how many gays did you beat up? How many did you stone to death for their unnatural acts?”

The fourth person was taken aback, and said “None! That’s assault and murder! Hurting people is the OPPOSITE of what you always told us to do, isn’t it? Besides, you didn’t expect me to break the laws of the country I lived in, did you?”

The voice roared “The only law that matters is MINE! No, you do not belong in my kingdom either. Go to the next door.”

All four, very puzzled to be lumped together in the same group, and feeling hurt by their rejection, made their way to the next door, a narrow wooden door. Before that door stood an unwashed, brown-skinned, bare-footed, long-haired man, who appeared to be no longer young but not yet middle-aged. He opened the door for them and said to them all, “Welcome to Heaven, children. Your sins are forgiven. Come on in through this door.”

The four were stunned by the words, and asked, “What? Didn’t God just tell us we weren’t welcome into his Kingdom?”

The man pushed back his hair, revealing a crown of thorns. He smiled and said “No, that wasn’t Dad on the throne. That was Satan.”


© John M. Munzer